is there such a thing as "right to be heard"? It's revealed that the events of the film transpire in accordance to plans laid out by the time traveling Protagonist. New York, The people in the future believe that reversing the entropy Why do the protagonist plan to retrieve the original painting from the freeport in Tenet? | Where is Sator between the Vietnam Yacht and Italy? Thats why its much easier to destroy something than to construct something. I like to imagine that the future generation is sending IPO information al la Forrest Gump investing in Apple. Your impression is correct, it doesn't work. Christopher Nolan's time traveling adventure Tenet, starring John David Washington, Robert Pattinson and Elizabeth Debicki, is now in theaters across the world. So where was he? from being buried in the hypocentre, one of the logical conditions for the "FutureErasesThePast" function to be called is not fulfilled. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. She was deeply hurt when Sator coerced her not to see Max again. Instructions are to press a button on the side, and boom! She said, Entropy is the measure of the level of order or the level of information. On average, things get more and more disorganized. What were the most popular text editors for MS-DOS in the 1980s? Compared to previous movies, like Interstellar, the gap is maybe bigger. The mistake here is the following statement, since Sator digs out the capsule and retrieves the gold, there must be a moment when the same gold is both in Sators hands and under the ground, from the perspective of the inverted capsule. Why refined oil is cheaper than cold press oil? You could also imagine that README file from the future was dumbed down to account for only components and technology readily available at the end of the 20th century. There is some element of physics. Expect views, reviews and news. What is Wario dropping at the end of Super Mario Land 2 and why? Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. It is not sure if Sator even knows how to trigger or detonate the algorithm. What you described (inverting ourselves and then retrieve gold) is a mechanism to prevent the "supposed paradox." Theres a really fundamental law in physics telling us that entropy always increases. Their whole idea was to erase the past to save the future. During the break in The Protagonist breaks a lock pick off inside of one of the doors, presumably a death sentence in this situation. They can't change the past and "erase" things, since, as Neil says, what's happened happened. Do you know the answers to some of these questions? The unknown future agent knew Sator would be there to discover the buried and inverted cache. U4PPP Lieu dit "Rotstuden" 67320 WEYER Tl. Is Arepo Neil, who already shows skill as an international fixer? The tenet universe follows a "block universe" model, a.k.a, "What's happened, happened." The Protagonist has been the man in charge of Tenet all along. I did have Kip Thorne read the script and he helped me out with some of the concepts, though were not going to make any case for this being scientifically accurate, Nolan said in the films press notes. With that out of the way, let's hop into question number one. Each generation looks out for its own survival. This may seem like another high class art dealer with a fancy name, but Arepo is actually connected to the film via the Sator Square, a famous latin palindrome. How could this be explained? Be safe. Sator digs it up and keeps it for a year, at which point the gold's trajectory breaks down completely as its supposed to be put into the ground on December 31st but in actuality its been melted down and used for other purposes. You may recognize Sator as the surname of Kenneth Branagh's Russian villain, Andrei Sator. @galacticninja Hmm fare point. I guess it could be used by forward people to just as well. Presumably the two are in for some hijinks that take place in the past. Why typically people don't use biases in attention mechanism? Finally, it goes back underground when the bulldozer goes in reverse. Please take the. We give the updated Mercenaries mode in Resident Evil 4 Remake a spin in this S-Rank gameplay clip, featuring Leon. So my question is, was the initial Goya drawing that fooled Kat also a plant by The Protagonist just to establish the toxic relationship between her and Sator? He has already experienced the events of the film, and stuff that happens after it ends. We only see big bulky turnstiles in the movie, because Stator needs those devices large enough to contain people and maybe even bigger objects. Just before Sator annihilates mankind he retreats to his last moment of true peace on his yacht with Kat. In the final scenes of Tenet it is revealed that all the good guys, even The Protagonist, were working for the 'future' version of The Protagonist all along. Kat: Let me go if I agreed never to see my son again. Protagonist: I'd like to say That you don't have to do this, Kat But Sator couldn't have removed the original set of gold (or any other object) from it's capsule, as doing so would create a paradox? An unknown agency is working with Sator to kill everyone in the past, because they're responsible. Embedded hyperlinks in a thesis or research paper. But from Gold bar's perspective, Sator buried it in the ground. Has the cause of a rocket failure ever been mis-identified, such that another launch failed due to the same problem? Expect views, reviews and news. He is then abducted and tortured until he bites on an apparent suicide pill before revealing any information. In a film that has very little emotional investment my question is why? It's my opinion--backed up from the script, though there are minor inconsistencies between that script and the film as shot--that those other answers you mentioned ignore key elements of the film in pursuit of their own interpretations. There is no paradox as far as the rules of the Tenet universe are concerned. The link doesn't help give closure to people who are reading this thread. rev2023.5.1.43404. He was a Russian oligarch used by future generations At the beginning of the film, an Esquire article attempts to explain, the Protagonist meets Clmence Posys scientist, who informs him that at some point in the future, a technology is invented that can reverse the entropy of people and objects. The tech has been monopolised in the future by a Russian oligarch named Andrei Sator, who has created an algorithm that allows him to invert his entropy, via turnstiles. In Kiev, Ukraine, an unnamed operative, The Protagonist (John David Washington), assists in a CIA assignment to foil an opera siege and retrieve a stolen cache of plutonium. Protagonist: How could they wanna kill us? Their plan is to crash a plane into the facility, trigger the fire alarms and hold their breath long enough to crack into Sator's secure warehouse. But where is that version during the events of the film? When he dies, the fuse goes off. Its future is @galacticninja your answer to that assumes that after being buried, it appears instantly in the future (it's waved off as from the future's perspective it's instantaneous). Despite what you may have heard, Tenet isnt really about time-travel--its about time manipulation. The people in the future (posterity) are expecting Sator to send them the location of the assembled algorithm (inside the capsule / dead drop), so they could get it in the future and trigger it then. But the minds behind activating the algorithm decided that it was worth the risk because they were screwed anyway. Anything that goes into the record speaks directly to the future. Ralisation Bexter. Mentions lgales Maybe oil field locations? Seriously, if you don't want to be spoiled venture forth at your own risk. | Directed by James Mangold, the movie also stars Phoebe Waller-Bridge, Antonio Banderas, John Rhys-Davies, Shaunette Renee Wilson, Thomas Kretschmann, Toby Jones, Boyd Holbrook, Oliver Richters, Ethann Isidore, and Mads Mikkelsen. Sator is okay with this because he has a terminal disease and doesnt want the world to live on after him. Bonus question: why was the gold brought to Sator by helicopter inverted, rather than normal, given the only possible mechanism for retrieving it? Does she meet up with 'past' Sator again to ensure she endures the suffering just so that it leads to the success of team Tenet? He is later awakened inside a thermal blanket, saved by Neil and his crew. Does interacting with an uninverted object while inverted invert said object? In the mean time, stay up to date on all the latest Tenet coverage with the team at CinemaBlend. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Is this a constant battle spanning generation over generation that The Protagonist and his team must constantly fight? Copyright HT Digital Streams Ltd. All rights reserved. Win/win, right? Not to get into a physics lesson, but inversion is this idea of material that has had its entropy inverted, so its running backwards through time, relative to us., Nolan consulted Nobel laureate Kip Thorne on Tenet -- Thorne also worked with the filmmaker on Interstellar -- but ended up relegating some of his suggestions. ", assuming we interpret "killing Grandpa" as the entropic destruction of the present and "consequence" as the concurrent entropic destruction of the future. We don't know, but we can certainly imagine and that is part of the magic of Tenet. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? WebThe algorithm will be created in the future by a future scientist as a way to turn back time since their future Earth is ruined by decisions made by present-day humans. It works long enough to enjoy the movie, but at some point it breaks down. In Tenet, how is this character able to retrieve the original cache of buried gold? Criticism for the film seems to be focussed on two things: its complicated plot and unclear sound mixing. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prsentation Galavanting around with Neil in the past? In short, a Temporal Pincer Movement is when one person goes back in time and informs someone else in the past how events will unfold in their future. It is At the end of Tenet Neil (Robert Pattinson), tells The Protagonist that their friendship is just beginning. Sator says that he is not destroying the world, but "creating a new one" (for the people in the future). There are a number of events that couldn't happen the way they do. That's incorrect: let's say you bury the inverted gold on Dec 31st and want Sator to dig it up on January 1st. There are a lot of times where they use science jargon and its just jargon with no content, she said. In fact, he couldn't retrieve any object sent from the future without creating a paradox, thus making it impossible for the interactions with the future to begin in earnest. Surely the future knows that their plan fails, since they send the Stalsk-12 time capsule for young Sator and don't instantly receive results (plutonium explosion in the sinkhole). When entropy increases, it means things are becoming less and less organized., Entropy out of the way, Tenet also deals with a concept of inversion, which an Empire article explains as: Inversion is a process whereby an object (or person) has its entropy reversed, essentially flipping its chronology so that from that point on it travels backwards in time instead of forwards.. Protagonist: But not you. It is necessary for the plot, intuitively it is a possiblility that time reversal gives, but if you think of it enough you see that it cannot work. Why was it important to stop the Algorithm from being dropped into the time capsule? You see the gold fall out of Sators hand since the scene is moving backwards. Have a theory that explains something I missed? Pourquoi choisir une piscine en polyester ? Throughout the film, it is shown that Kat cares very much for her son, Max. My head hurts just rereading that sentence. buries a capsule, transmits the coordinates (presumably via a hidden newspaper message or an equivalent), Looks like Sator's tracker then triggers a minor fuse which causes the algorithm to cause a nuclear Armageddon. Plan du site escapades he must go on to prevent the Algorithm it's definitely a possibility. In reverse, he puts it into the capsule, and it goes off to the turnstile. Neil: It'll be linked Not quite the only thing that is nonsensical about the film though. I'll be sure to keep my eyes peeled for sharp dressed background characters in my next viewing. 03 88 01 24 00, U2PPP "La Mignerau" 21320 POUILLY EN AUXOIS Tl. People in the future talk to Sator by You could see Sator doing this since he would know that he has a forward-moving capsule elsewhere. Protagonist: [To Kat] You're not there to kill him, you're the backstop. What we haven't established is how he connects to the larger picture and if he may be involved with The Protagonist. Very late to the party, but being able to rewatch Tenet numerous times on HBOMax (with subtitles!) How can the future protect themselves by wiping out the past in Tenet? Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. What were the poems other than those by Donne in the Melford Hall manuscript. Of course, what the movie did not depict was Sator putting everything back into the capsule (forward in time) for his inverted henchman to go bury it (the reverse of him digging it up). If Sator's dead man's switch was meant to trigger the algorithm, then it's "end of play"to use Neil's wordsas soon as Sator got killed. Tenet believes that Sators plan will come into effect on the 14th (the month is unspecified). Activating the algorithm was a Hail Mary failsafe to destroy one generation so that it will reverse the damage done to the future generation. I realize we dont actually see any inverted people in the scene, but thats how I could see it happening. If so, how was it inverted? In the future, they have the ability to greatly miniaturize their turnstile technology to fit within the time capsule, and besides, this is their smaller model, only needed to be big enough to accommodate the initial gold bar shipment. What I like about the diagram is that, after the empty capsule is buried, the next thing that happens is both regular gold and inverted gold suddenly come out of the turnstile much like The Protagonist and the inverted Protagonist suddenly coming out of the turnstile at the Oslo Freeport. I agree with the eternal conflict of present vs the future, and the future has to get lucky only once, but changing perspective from present to the future doesnt make the time capsule appear in the future. Now that I think of it, the people from the future could have burried a complete working turnstile. Throughout Tenet The Protagonist is constantly bending over backwards for Kat. Note the words: "backstop" and "and". Is there a situation where the future can go back and make some minor tweaks to the timeline, like knocking off The Protagonist before the events of the film? Can someone explain how Kat experienced this part of Tenet from her perspective? If the gold has been burried in a specific location for Sator to discover at some specific time and place, then the future of the gold after the discovery is to be burried. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Many of them we've gone over already but none of them were as fascinating to me as 'Where was the 'future' version of The Protagonist' the entire time'? Why did DOS-based Windows require HIMEM.SYS to boot? Counting and finding real solutions of an equation. You can figure it out by thinking of how that inverted gold bar gets to the future (not in the capsule). By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. It will spread and get more and more disorganized. The Los Angeles Times spoke with Claudia De Rham, a theoretical physicist from Imperial College London, and asked her if the science in the film holds up. The film makes it all clear that the Future has identified Sator as the man to end the world in his time. She's killed him. Hi Zonker, do you have any sources to back your theory up? What's the cheapest way to buy out a sibling's share of our parents house if I have no cash and want to pay less than the appraised value? | This happens after years of correspondence and presumably many, many deliveries from the future. Alternatively, that gold bar was actually a regular bar that came out of the turnstile. You jumped the gun! We haven't been shown anything in the movie which contradicts that. | I've got a feeling for your thoughts on the matter already, but as the writer of the "very long and convoluted" answer I've found that there's an internal consistency to the film (centered on determinism) if you keep digging at it. | Sator has a dead man's switch which will detonate the algorithm and reverse entropy, ending the world. This diagram is the best/only drawing I could find on the internet depicting the path of the inverted gold. Bringing death to all, because Esquire explained, The Protagonist inverted himself in the future, set up the whole mission, then went on to recruit Neil and arm him with the information he needed to help. I'm going to see the film a second time in a few days. It just sends out the location of the dead drop (the buried capsule). But what if a random person stumbled on the gold bars. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. The diagram is confusing because it doesn't specify that. view detail. The film never gives us confirmation on Arepo's identity but because of the connection to the Sator Square, The Protagonist's inversion abilities and the future - (err past?) In fact, we see that those current-day scientists are discovering random inverted stuff all over the place. Why pick the lock if you already know the codes? Of course, Sator wouldnt be able to use that first stash of gold since he needs to re-bury it. Despite not knowing he constantly goes to bat for her. We learn that Sator communicates with people from the future and, as a result, gets an advantage in terms of information. We are told that you can never, under any circumstances interact with your past self, which is why The Protagonist wears special gear when inverting into the Goya heist. Except, both sides are actually experiencing it simultaneously.. It ends with a revelation. Protagonist: Kat! Does he have a romantic relationship with her? Is it all just a last ditch effort scenario? To do this they have to bust into an ultra secure free port. Currently this seems to be purely speculation, for which the Stack Exchange network is not the right format. Thus you have inverted and un-inverted Tenet soldiers fighting against Sators men, while The Protagonist and Ives (played by a near-unrecognisable Aaron Taylor-Johnson), both on the red team, head down into the bunker to nab the Algorithm, Empire continued. Ralisations @MovieMe There is no "time and place" their world ends aside from the "sometime, somewhere" of the man the in crystalline tower. Imagine an inverted henchman dug up the capsule and brought it immediately to the yacht. Why isn't Sator 2 (inverted Sator) wearing an oxygen mask when he goes back to his yacht in Vietnam for his final moment? It doesn't instantaneously time travel to the future. But in the movie you just see the capsule being dug out. After this reveal the Protagonist calls Sator a traitor to his own generation. Their main goal is their survival, to save their own world, whose environment is so degraded that it can barely support life. Kat: A chance to help save my child. When a gnoll vampire assumes its hyena form, do its HP change? Sator: When I'm done, life continues. Perhaps one of those hijinks is planting not just a second Goya, but also the first under the pseudonym Arepo? The paradox of digging up the original inverted capsule can be easily resolved by Sator re-burying the capsule back where he found it. When Kat shoots Sator, why doesn't the algorithm detonate? The Sator The Protagonist will soon master the art of "time inversion" as a way of countering the threat that is to come. We learn one of Furthermore, The Protagonist realizes that the opera was being bombed and so he collects the bombs to save the people. The "dead man's switch" (Sator's fitness tracker) is not connected to the time bomb in the hypocentre: Key term is in effect; the email has no role in activating the algorithm, it's a signal to the future that allows the reality in which the algorithm is activated to exist. Conseils He is doing all of this inverted for the first time. Tenet believes that Sators plan will come into effect on the 14th (the month is unspecified). De Rham also explained the concept of entropy. When the credits rolled and Travis Scott's The Plan started playing, I had a lot of questions going through my head, obviously. Unbeknownst to him he is actually hanging out with the 'future' Kat who knows his plans and is attempting to keep him alive long enough to prevent the activation of The Algorithm. Passing negative parameters to a wolframscript, "Signpost" puzzle from Tatham's collection. The rule of the tenet universe prevents it. There is some element of science. While The Protagonist is in the car, the heat from the explosion starts to freeze the windows and he blacks out as the car explodes. I doubt it. This is known as The Grandfather Paradox and is mentioned in the film. Kat killed Sator knowing that it will just send the location of the algorithm to posterity, and not that it will trigger armageddon. That algorithm would have been buried in case. Or maybe it's another member of The Protagonist's time traveling team. On the other side, Sator has a dead man's switch which will detonate the algorithm and reverse entropy, ending the world. In the movie, reverse time has its own logic that is explained to some length. Thus, the path of the inverted capsule into the past would be: the capsule is underground until it comes out of the ground (the reverse of Sator burying the capsule). Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. While one very long and convoluted (read subjective) answer is accepted, the other answers are in the exact opposite direction and have solid points too. Scan this QR code to download the app now. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Because the rivers froze over and their world had been polluted to the point of no return. A Tenet member would not need the capacity to make tough choices, they can just receive the objectively correct course of action to follow from the future. New blog post from our CEO Prashanth: Community is the future of AI, Improving the copy in the close modal and post notices - 2023 edition.
Shooting In Whittier Today,
How To Get Ark Primal Fear On Xbox One,
House For Rent In Villa Angela Bacolod City,
How Do I Get Discovery Plus On Bt Tv,
Articles T